Skip to main content

40 "Would You Rather" Questions to Spice Up Your Thanksgiving Gathering

Explore fun Thanksgiving "Would You Rather" questions for kids, teens, and adults to spark laughter and connection.
Thanksgiving turkey
Updated: October 11, 2024
Table of contents

Thanksgiving is a time for family, friends, and feasting. While the aroma of turkey fills the air, why not stir up some fun with "Would You Rather" questions? These playful prompts are a fantastic way to break the ice, fill gaps in conversation, and get everyone laughing. Whether you're entertaining kids, teenagers, or adults, these questions will keep the festive spirit alive and create memorable moments.

Kids' "Would You Rather" Questions for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving party

Get ready to tickle young minds and spark giggles with these kid-friendly dilemmas tailored for Turkey Day fun!

  1. Would you rather have a turkey that says "gobble gobble" every time you look at it or a pie that sings every time you cut it?

    A hilarious choice for the little ones, this question is sure to get giggles.   

  2. Would you rather eat mashed potatoes with your hands or have to pop a balloon every time you take a bite?

    Mixing food and fun, this dilemma will tickle kids’ imaginations.

  3. Would you rather have feathers instead of hair or a beak instead of a nose?

    Transforming into a turkey never sounded so amusing!

  4. Would you rather have cranberry sauce for fingers or stuffing for toes?

    An odd but delightful question that lets kids be creative.

  5. Would you rather talk like a turkey or walk like a penguin?

    Perfect for encouraging silly walks and funny voices.

  6. Would you rather watch a parade of marching pumpkins or dancing scarecrows?

    Inspire imagination as kids think up whimsical scenes.

  7. Would you rather have gravy rain or stuffing snow?

    A delightful dilemma that combines weather with Thanksgiving favorites.

  8. Would you rather have a pumpkin pie hat or a turkey leg necklace?

    Fashion meets food in this quirky question.

  9. Would you rather only be able to talk in gobbles or only be able to dance like a turkey?

    A question that invites plenty of laughter and turkey impersonations.

  10. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving feast with superheroes or cartoon characters?

    A perfect prompt for kids to bring their favorites to the table.

Teen "Would You Rather" Questions for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving isn't just for the kids or adults—teens can join the fun too! Check out these intriguing, laugh-inducing dilemmas perfect for shaking up the holiday spirit and getting everyone involved.

  1. Would you rather snap a selfie with a turkey or make a TikTok dance about Thanksgiving?

    Inviting teens to blend social media with holiday fun.

  2. Would you rather have a family dinner interrupted by aliens or by a famous celebrity?

    A question prompting out-of-this-world scenarios.

  3. Would you rather only listen to holiday music or only watch holiday movies for a month?

    Engage teens in choosing their seasonal entertainment.

  4. Would you rather have a magical ability to cook the perfect turkey or make the perfect pumpkin pie?

    Ideal for aspiring chefs with a magical twist.

  5. Would you rather text in emojis for a day or have to call everyone to chat?

    A tech-themed choice that challenges communication styles.

  6. Would you rather attend a Friendsgiving with your buddies or Thanksgiving with your favorite band?

    Mixes friendship with fan moments.

  7. Would you rather spend Black Friday working or shopping?

    A real-world dilemma with real-world consequences.

  8. Would you rather have the power to make leaves fall or to make snowflakes fly?

    Inviting creativity with control over the seasons.

  9. Would you rather have a time machine to revisit Thanksgivings past or see into future celebrations?

    A time-travel question encouraging reflection and imagination.

  10. Would you rather write and direct a Thanksgiving play or have the lead role in one?  

    Perfect for budding actors and directors.

Family-Friendly "Would You Rather" Questions for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving party

When the whole family gathers around for Thanksgiving, these fun "Would You Rather" questions will add a unique flavor to the festivities that everyone can enjoy.

  1. Would you rather eat only dessert for a week or never have dessert again?

    A sweet dilemma to debate over the table.

  2. Would you rather have to wear a turkey costume to work/school or only eat Thanksgiving leftovers for a month?

    This will get everyone pondering priorities.

  3. Would you rather help cook the meal or clean up afterwards?

    A practical question that might even lead to some volunteer chefs!

  4. Would you rather eat a Thanksgiving meal with no utensils or without any drinks?

    This choice tests dining skills and thirst tolerance.

  5. Would you rather have Thanksgiving dinner at the North Pole or on a beach?

    A fun way to discuss ideal holiday settings.

  6. Would you rather have a real turkey as a pet or have to name your firstborn "Turkey"?

    Get the family laughing with this identity dilemma.

  7. Would you rather see a football game in person or watch a Thanksgiving parade live?

    Sparking debates about the best Thanksgiving traditions.

  8. Would you rather host a big Thanksgiving dinner or attend one?

    Discuss preferences for being a host or a guest.

  9. Would you rather have to say what you’re thankful for in rhyme or in song?

    Perfect for a creative twist on gratitude.

  10. Would you rather have a pie-eating contest or a stuffing-eating contest?  

    A fun question that highlights favorite foods.

Adult "Would You Rather" Questions for Thanksgiving

Get ready to spice up the grown-up table with playful and thought-provoking questions that promise laughter and lively discussions among friends and family!

  1. Would you rather cook the entire Thanksgiving meal or wash all the dishes afterward?

    A grown-up question that tackles kitchen responsibilities.

  2. Would you rather host Thanksgiving for your in-laws or your boss?

    A strategic choice with a touch of humor.

  3. Would you rather discuss politics or avoid controversial topics at the dinner table?

    A realistic choice faced by many during family gatherings.

  4. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving meal with historical figures or fictional characters?

    A thought-provoking question for the imaginative adult.

  5. Would you rather drink only eggnog with your meal or pumpkin spice lattes?

    A beverage battle for seasonal favorites.

  6. Would you rather play football in the backyard or organize a board game tournament?

    A question that pits physical activity against strategy.

  7. Would you rather have to eat everything with chopsticks or with your hands?

    Testing table manners and dexterity.

  8. Would you rather have a Thanksgiving feast with no talking or only talking about gratitude?

    Encouraging reflection and mindfulness.

  9. Would you rather relive the same Thanksgiving every year or try a different cuisine each time?

    A question exploring tradition versus variety.

  10. Would you rather do a turkey trot (run) or a pie-eating contest before the meal?  

    Balancing fitness with fun.

Festive "Would You Rather" Questions for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is a time for reflection and gratitude, but it's also about creating joyful memories with loved ones. Using "Would You Rather" questions is a surefire way to sprinkle a bit of humor into your holiday gatherings. Share these questions as you gather around the table and watch as conversations and laughter unfold. Who knows, you might even start a new Thanksgiving tradition!

Check out 40 Spine-Chillingly Fun "Would You Rather" Questions for Halloween for more fun, or 40 Festive "Would You Rather" Questions for Christmas!

Tara Gunn

About Tara

Hailing from Canada, Tara is a graduate of Scotland's University of St. Andrews in creative… Read more

Join the Family

Your partner in parenting from baby name inspiration to college planning.

Subscribe