Daycare Problems

Here's the deal...our two children, ages two and three, are cared for,during the day ,by my aunt who has taken care of all of my nieces, nephews, cousins, etc.,... Currently, she has four children under her care -- my nephew,age four, my cousin's daughter,age three, and my two. At least twice a week I can count on having a heated discussion with my husband concerning the quality of the care they are receiving. My daughter, the two-year-old, comes home with scratches on her face on a daily basis. My son,age three, almost as often. The scratches are inflicted by my cousin's daughter. She has a real problem and I have mentioned it to her parents several times. She doesn't have long nails, but knows how to use her little stubs to do the damage. (Smart kid, huh?)

My husband gets upset when he sees the scratches and I do too, but what can we do?

We can't afford daycare. While we do pay my aunt, we don't pay her nearly as much as we would pay at daycare. My husband insists that my aunt does not watch them, and he says,"I don't know what she does, but she's not watching them." I usually ask my aunt what happened and she says that it happened so fast she couldn't stop them before they started fighting. She has told me repeatedly that she never leaves the room without at least one of the children. She mainly takes my cousin's daughter with her since she's the scratcher.

I feel this is a phase that the girl is going through but my husband has no tolerance for it. I also need to mention that I have seen my children in action and they are no angels. They fight with each other, mainly hitting, and they pick on each other when they're bored. When I remind my husband of that he doesn't admit it. My aunt has told me that my son hits the scratcher and she reacts by doing what she does best!

I personally don't think my aunt can't be watching them every second and I can see how these things can happen in a split second, but my husband doesn't believe it. I'm not saying my aunt is the perfect babysitter, but who is? I know I'm not!

Also, a couple weeks ago my husband decided it was time for him to say something to my aunt, of course, I tried to stop him but couldn't. My aunt told me that the next day my son said, "Lauren scratched me, my dad's going to call you." The epitome of brattiness in my opinion. He has already begun to equate Lauren with scratches, so even if she is not the cause, that is who he blames.

How do we deal with this? After a hard day of work this is not something either of us wants to argue about.

A final note: My husband just read this email and said I'm defending my aunt too much and that I am being too one-sided. PLEASE HELP. I'm in the middle . I love them both and no longer know what to do!!!